Capsule review: it mostly sucked.
More specific annoyances follow.
- A cyborg with bronchitis? What the hell?
- Palpatine’s tranformation from sinister manipulator to gibbering deformed madman over the course of a single fight scene.
- The way you could tell what was meant to be significant dialogue because it was spoken… in… ponderous… leaden… monotone…
I do wonder how it is that all of these people who can genuinely act fail to do it when they’re all in the same film. - The word “younglings”. For heaven’s sake. This is not the seventies. We don’t need to replace perfectly good words with stupid ones just because we’re in space.
- C-3PO and R2D2 should not have been split up. R2 was good, 3PO was reduced to walking on screen, saying “oh my!” or similar, and walking off again. About fifteen times.
- Given that Jedi are supposed to be supremely attuned to the universe around them, how come so many of them got shot in the back?
- Crowbar continuity. “We have to foreshadow all these things whether it makes sense to do so or not!”
- Ironically, bad continuity. 20 years on Tatooine are clearly not going to be kind to Kenobi.
- My big question about this film before seeing it was: how would they transform Anakin from the sulky teen of episode 2 to the badass Dark Lord of episode 4? Answer: They didn’t. By the end, he’s just a sulky teen in a black mask. His last line to Obi-Wan: “I hate you!” I’m sure he would have added “It’s so unfair!” had his lungs not been on fire.
I guess the transformation happens some time in the intervening 20 or so years.
The whole thing felt like some Star Wars fanfic author had won the lottery and decided to turn one of his terrible stories into film. “And, er, let’s put Chewie in! Yeah! Maybe, like, Yoda knew him or something!”
There were some good bits, though.
- Hot Yoda Lightsaber Action. Once again we see him as the Jedi Master.
- Grievous with four lightsabers was pretty cool.
- Er. Jar Jar wasn’t in it much.
- …


